Copay coupons like the ones Mylan offers for EpiPens allows drug companies to use consumers as tools to push insurance companies and therefore consumers to overpay for drugs. The copay coupon means an insured consumer often pays less "out of pocket" for the more expensive drug.
In the case of EpiPen which sell for $600, in some cases more, the consumer with an insurance plan that only requires copays for drugs or a consumer that has already met a deductible pays zero out of pocket if they have a copay coupon dumping a $500 bill on the insurance company. Instead of purchasing the $144 generic available at Walmart.
Walmart/GoodRx Adrenaclick $144.62
Lifehacker--Adrenaclick
Of course while consumers think they are tricking the insurance company, we are really tricking themselves since the insurance company just passes the extra cost back to us in higher premiums.
When Massachusetts dropped the ban on copay coupons they were warned that it would cost Massachusetts consumers $100s of millions or even billions in higher drug costs and insurance premiums. By the looks of how fast drug costs and insurance premiums are rising, those estimates may be low. Of course that only covers one small state. Imagine how much this costs when the entire country is included since Massachusetts is only 2% of the population.
http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/repealing-brand-drug-copay-coupons-ban-increases-costs-by-750-million-for-massachusetts-employers-unions-and-state-employee-health-programs-159043445.html
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2016/06/08/drug-co-pay-assistance-programs-facing-increasing-state-federal-scrutiny/85547788/
I intend to create a list of drugs where the copay coupon has created severe artificial imbalances in the free market. Inflating prices while giving unfairly large market share to the most expensive options. If anyone knows of examples leave a comment.
Monday, August 29, 2016
Wednesday, August 17, 2016
OPEC has some Major Problems if they cap production, US and Canadian Producers will eat their lunch
US crude oil is clearly rising again and this doesn't bode well for any move by OPEC, Russia, et.al. to cap or cut production. It is pretty clear now that the situation for North American producers has drastically changed. Any price support, especially any surge close to WTI $50 will result in rapid US and Canadian production increases. It is also pretty clear that while most--including me--expected a major decline in US production towards a level well below 9MM BPD, it is now clear that 9MM BPD is the floor and US production is rising again along with working oil rig counts.
There is a clear surge in unaccounted for oil dating back to June. A surge in unaccounted for oil, especially a sustained one is a leading indicator that US production is rising, even though the official production number continued to show decline. However, the official production number showed a huge 100k BPD increase last week.
Not only is US production rising, but it appears Canadian production is surging as well with US imports from Canada surging over 3.3MM BPD last week. Comparing to last year, Canadian imports surged well over 3.3MM BPD in late 2015 and early 2016 in the face of oil in the low $40s and $30s. I expect more of the same this fall and winter.
Those betting on a sustained rally in prices today are in for a surprise as we are heading into fall maintenance refinery maintenance season with a corresponding huge slump in demand just as US and Canadian output is surging. That can't be good for prices.
There is a clear surge in unaccounted for oil dating back to June. A surge in unaccounted for oil, especially a sustained one is a leading indicator that US production is rising, even though the official production number continued to show decline. However, the official production number showed a huge 100k BPD increase last week.
US Production and Unaccounted for Oil
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-8-17
Not only is US production rising, but it appears Canadian production is surging as well with US imports from Canada surging over 3.3MM BPD last week. Comparing to last year, Canadian imports surged well over 3.3MM BPD in late 2015 and early 2016 in the face of oil in the low $40s and $30s. I expect more of the same this fall and winter.
Canadian Crude Exports to the US
Data Source: EIA
psw08 2016-4-27
Those betting on a sustained rally in prices today are in for a surprise as we are heading into fall maintenance refinery maintenance season with a corresponding huge slump in demand just as US and Canadian output is surging. That can't be good for prices.
Friday, August 5, 2016
Glowing June and July BLS Non-Farm Job Reports are Totally Bogus, More to Come
Seasonally Adjusted Non-Farm Jobs Change 2013-Present: Comparison between Griz Method/Simple YoY and BLS Monthly Reports
Source Data: BLS
Total Nonfarm 2016-8. xlsx
Seasonally Adjusted Non-Farm Jobs Change 2013-Present with 2016 Projections: Comparison between Griz Method/Simple YoY and BLS Monthly Reports and my projections from June 2016 for monthly gains using the Griz Method and my expectations for the BLS reports.
Source Data: BLS
Total Nonfarm 2016-8. xlsx
Even though I knew this months great jobs report "surprise" was coming, it still amazes me to watch this unfold right in front of my eyes. In early June I correctly predicted huge "surprises" to come in the monthly jobs reports. I Hope Everyone is Expecting Huge Gains in the Non-Farms Job Report in July, August and September just as I did in November, 2015. Huge October Jobs Report Coming I also found it interesting that the experts didn't see this coming, although I've seen at least one quoted saying the real job gain number is 150k-200k per month. Well it looks like the truth hides in plain sight.
I've shown the most recent BLS reported monthly job gains along with the gains calculated with my methods with the chart of what I predicted in June was coming. It is really scary just how close my projections have been for both the BLS report and my estimates of what the Griz method would show in coming months. It is clear to see I projected that gains would follow the lower trend line as shown in the lower chart, which has now been confirmed by 2 months of reports as shown in the upper chart. I expect this will continue to year end.
I also projected that huge reports were in store, although I thought it was possible the really big numbers would be delayed to later in the year. What is clear is I saw the big numbers coming.
It is also clear US stocks have broken out to the upside since the June report and are getting another bullish push today. While the very bearish reports early this year helped inflate US treasuries which are getting knocked down since June with only the Brexit scare driving them up. Treasuries are getting hit again today and I expect they will continue to get driven down as rate hike talk gets serious again driven by month after month of great job reports.
I also find it quite "convenient" that now that Hillary is pushing a story of how great things are, that the jobs numbers suddenly went from miserable to start the year, to totally amazing the last 2 months. That when my analysis clearly shows job growth rates are in decline and have been for most of a year. My analysis shows the early part of the year was much stronger than the last few months, yet the BLS seasonal adjustment is showing that the last 2 months have been the strongest of the year, rivaling the fastest growth we have seen in 2 years.
Thursday, June 9, 2016
Continuing unemployment claims do NOT support holding off rate hikes
US Continuing Unemployment Claims 2005 to Present and YoY
Data Source: US Department of Labor
Unemployment weekly 2015-4-9.xlsx
The most recent BLS jobs report for May 2016 implied that US employment is totally in the tank providing cover for the Fed to continue to hold off on interest rate hikes. However, continuing unemployment claims along with the BLS own nonadjusted data does not indicate the jobs market is as bad as the May 38k gain implies.
I find it very suspicious that conditions now justify a funds rate below 1% helping to hold the US 10 year treasury below 10% while in the 2007 timeframe the economy was clearly grinding to a halt but the funds rate was in the 3-5% range helping to hold the 10 year treasury in the 5-6% range. It is pretty clear that low treasury rates and low interest on margin debt are keeping investors in very expensive risky stock assets at this point since treasuries do not offer an attractive return.
How is it that with continuing claims at a lower absolute level than around 2007 with a larger working aged population that these low rates can be justified? Moral of this story is they can't. I expect we'll see a major spike in rates post election.
Wednesday, June 8, 2016
Summer Demand Has Yet to Dent Gasoline Inventory, Will It?
US Gasoline Inventory, YoY
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-1-13
US gasoline inventories are 10% over the same time last year or about 22.3MM bbl over last years storage level. It is no wonder gasoline crack spreads are about $10 lower than this time last year. The fact that inventory levels appear to be flattening and even surged last week is a warning that gasoline demand may not be nearly as high this summer as many expected early on. It has become my feeling that many stockpiled gasoline at lower prices this late winter and spring which could have lasting affects on early summer demand. If refiners have been running at higher rates with the expectation of huge demand based on the huge spring demand they could be in real trouble if they don't slow down soon as crack spreads are already poor and could get a lot worse this fall when demand lags if they continue to carry this inventory. I'm betting they will be running at much lower utilization levels than expected for this time of year putting heavy pressure on crude demand.
Rather than seeing a large surge in summer gasoline demand we could actually see much softer demand as we did in 2014, if gasoline was indeed stockpiled this spring as the unexplained exceptionally high gasoline demand suggests.
US Gasoline Supplied, YoY
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-4-27
I'm shorting crude oil with the expectation that the power is in the hands of the refiners with high inventories on both sides of their process and really unlimited supplies yet worldwide. I find it likely they will slowdown which will support gasoline somewhat, but will crush crude. They could easily manage to create gasoline draws and crude builds. The situation with gasoline and distillates implies refiners could slow as much as 10% to draw refined inventories within historical seasonal norms. That would be 1.5MM bbl day which would create 7MM+ bbl/day excess crude. So we could be looking at 3.5MM-7MM barrel builds in crude this summer.
Time to Short Distillates/Heating Oil
Distillate Inventory,YoY
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-4-27
Given rapidly rising heating oil prices over the last several weeks does anyone see a problem? It looks like distillates and heating oil by proxy (/HO) is ready for a good downturn as we are headed into the time of year when distillate inventories build due to lack of demand. One can easily see in the chart below that distillate demand sags from June through September. Distillates supplied averages about 3.8 MM bbl/day from June to September. This is well below the April/May average which was about 4.1MM bbl/day. Given a 10% drop in demand producing rapidly rising inventories it looks like distillate prices should fall. High gasoline demand over the summer can also force refiners to continue to produce at higher rates than they like, storing the excess distillates rather than slowing down.
Distillate Inventory,YoY
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-4-27
I'll be emphasizing shorting /HO into early October. Currently short /HO futures.
Crude + Petroleum Products Inventory Set to Make New Record Highs, Crude Bulls Lookout
Total Crude + Petroleum Inventory
Data Source: EIA
psw01 2016-1-13.xlsx
Total crude + Petroleum Products popped 3.2 million barrels last week and is only 2.5 millions barrels below the record high of 1.371 billions barrels set the week of April 29, 2016. The chart clearly shows summer into fall has a history of inventory builds, with huge builds continuing through the winter and spring of 2015/2016. A pattern similar to 2015, just slightly weaker is set to repeat. I expect total inventory to build to at least 1.4 billion barrels and possibly as high as 1.42 billion barrels. This can be seen by using the 2015 inventory level normalized to 2016 through June 3 as a projection line.
In the past inventory levels would fall late in the year. Studying the data it appears this was typically driven by drops in crude inventory driven by reduced imports from Saudi Arabia. It appears the Saudis were propping up the markets during weak demand times. However, it is clear that in 2014 and 2015 they did not do this. I expect that to remain the case in 2016 as Canadian oil sands producers have shown a drive to rapidly expand production even in the face of very low prices this past winter. Canadian imports shot above 3MM bbl per day to around 3.4MM bbl/day in January. That compared to a peak of about 2.8MM bbl/day in January 2014, which implies about a 20% YoY increase. A conservative projection puts Canadian imports at about 3.5MM bbl/day by July/August and 4MM bbl/day by January 2017 is not out of the question. The Saudis will not want to give up this market share. Indeed I fully expect many producers will get excited about dumping crude and refined products in the US now that crude is over $50 and Canadian imports are rising. With no OPEC agreement to cap production, producers will be forced to compete, driving down prices severely again, before there can be any serious talk of cooperation again.
One of the big problems that has been created this year for OPEC cooperation is the high prices have now given high cost producers in North America a great chance to expand and improve their hedges into spring of 2017. Unlike this past year I expect they will put in a solid floor around $45 so they do not lose money should prices drop into the $30s as they did last year. Most producers were seriously hurt because their collars didn't protect them below the $40 to $46 range.
I'm short oil and heating oil in my various accounts with DWTI and sold Calls on USO at $11.50 $12, and $12.50 in every available week out to January 2017. I'll continue to add to those covered calls with weekly profits and as options expire, possibly into February 2017. At this point I expect to remain generally short oil, buying a few of the dips at key support levels until February 2017.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








