Friday, March 4, 2016

Oil Traders Mindset Needs to Change on US Production Strength

I just saw a recent article where an author or analyst stated that US production for the week of Feb 26 was down 2.6% over the same week a year ago.  Why do so many in the mainstream media continue to downplay the drop in US production and have really been playing it up as being "strong", "robust" and "resilient".  Stating the efficiency improvements and cost reductions have made this possible.  While ignoring various other metrics that clearly show US production is falling fast and is far weaker than is being reported.

The table below clearly shows multiple data points that can be used to show a much more dramatic fall in production and more clearly show what is really happening.  The biggest story is the one told when Unaccounted for Oil is factored in.  Using unaccounted for oil it appears US production is 10% off peak, and when you look at the trend since Dec 4 it is falling off a cliff.  In fact I found an article on Bloomberg indicating that the global glut has been grossly overestimated and the inventory numbers show a much lower oversupply.   Another analyst was quoted in a Reuters article stating US production is falling much faster than most realize.

Oil Traders Mindset Needs to Change
EIA Overestimates US Production in Weekly Reports

US Production Change for Various Time Windows and Data Sets
Then Now% Change
2/27/2015, Weekly Data93249077-2.65%
6/5/2015, Weekly Data96109077-5.55%
1/15/2016, Weekly Data92359077-1.71%
Sept 2015, Monthly Data94529077-3.97%
April 2015, Monthly Data96949077-6.36%
7/17/2015, Prod + Unacc for Oil, 4 week averages98438881-9.77%

Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Gasoline Demand Remains Robust

This post is a followup to This is Why Refiners Didn't Act Like Gasoline Demand was Weak Last Week, Even if Traders Did and Refiners Aren't Acting Like Gasoline Demand is Weak, Even if Traders Are.  US refinery run rates remain high and gasoline demand is very strong pouring some cold water on the popularly held notion that crude and petroleum demand is terrible.
psw01 2016-2-18
A year over year comparison of gasoline supplied clearly indicates 2016 demand is well above 2015.  Year to date gasoline supplied is up 3% over 2015.  This is especially significant given for the same period in 2015 was up 5.1% over 2014.

psw01 2016-1-13
Refinery inputs are up 3% over 2015 as is gasoline supplied.

psw01 2016-1-13
Overall petroleum supplied is tracking 2015 levels well. 



Tuesday, March 1, 2016

Oil Traders Mindset on US Production Needs to Catch Up

psw01 2016-2-24
The mindset of many oil traders remains heavily bearish.  Many are in disbelief that prices can be rising with such severe oversupply remaining.  They cannot understand the incentive OPEC, Russia, Oman and others have to cap or even cut production.  The mindset remains one that US production has barely dropped and can increase dramatically on the smallest price increase.

This flawed mindset is produced by EIA weekly production estimates that have been wildly off the mark.  EIA monthly data and Unaccounted for Oil category in the weekly reports proves the weekly estimate varies wildly from reality.

In trading knowing the trend and especially knowing trend reversals is key.  A big problem arises when the easily interpreted reported data does not match up with the reality.

The above chart indicates why many traders do not fully embrace that US production is falling and falling fast, and will continue to fall fast.  Weekly reports have touted how "robust" US shale production has been in the face of low prices going back to early last fall.  Indeed if you look at the weekly production estimate it was flat to rising from September 2015 to mid January 2016.  But the monthly production data is telling a completely different story.  It shows US production clearly falling since September.  The problem is the monthly data lags by 2 months and many traders don't even follow the monthly reports.  Worse yet, the EIA monthly production forecasts had projected steady production increases through February 2016.  All the data has proven the rising forecasts to be wrong through December, and is indicating the January and February forecasts were wrong as well.

The traders that follow the mainstream media have the belief that US production has just started to fall and has only been falling for 3 weeks, when in reality US production has been falling for 5 months.  So most traders have a mistaken belief that it took sub $30 oil to get US production to fall when the reality is sub $45 oil had production falling, and sub $30 pretty much has producers in panic mode dropping about 25% of active rigs in a month.  The rig count is now about 400, which was the number in operation in 2009 to support total production levels around 5MM bbl/day.

This will lead to a mindset where many traders will continue to believe every move up in price will spur US producers to bring on more oil.  I even read an article stating that $40 is the new $70 and that as soon as $40 is hit to expect a big spike in output.  Recent history does not support that assertion.  Even the CEO of EOG has stated they will not look to boost output until prices remain above $60 for a considerable period.  I take that to mean 3 months or more since they moved in summer 2015 with 2 months over $60 and look what happened.  I believe WTI will actually end up hitting $70 before US production stabilizes and begins to rise.

The reason the Saudis are now supporting moves to support oil prices and get them on an uptrend is that it is now clear to them based on published data that oil prices are plenty low to kill off US and Canadian production, as well as other high cost producers.  It is clear that sub $45 had US production in decline and anything close to $30 was near panic mode.  This means they can allow prices to creap up about 50% with a negligible change in shale producers mode of operation.  Once drilling rigs are laid down, they will not come back into service until prices top $60.  In fact there is likely to be a slow decline in rig count until $60 is hit.

The chart below puts the US oil rig count in historical context with 2009 when prices were comparable.  When WTI price is included it is seen that in summer of 2015 rig counts began to rise after $60 was hit and the same is true for 2009.

North America Rotary Rig Count (Jan 2000-Current) 2016-2-19



Wednesday, February 24, 2016

This is Why Refiners Didn't Act Like Gasoline Demand was Weak Last Week, Even if Traders Did

psw01 2016-2-18
It appears there was a very good reason refineries were ramped up 2 weeks ago, gasoline demand was huge this past week.  For all the talk of weak demand even for gasoline, the numbers just don't support that story for gasoline.  Gasoline demand appears to be surging in recent weeks.  Year to Date gasoline demand is up 1.3% YoY but if we eliminate the first week of the year that was likely down excessively due to covering both the Christmas and New Years holidays, gasoline demand is up 2.6% YoY.


psw01 2016-1-3
The above chart shows refinery inputs are up significantly YoY as well.  The data indicates refinery inputs are up 2.6% for the YTD period vs. the same 2015 period.  If global demand is weak, US refineries sure aren't indicating that is the case.  
psw01 2016-1-13
In recent weeks total petroleum supplied has been surging putting it back in line with 2015 demand.  The next several weeks of 2015 showed a noticeable drop off in demand, it will be interesting to see if the same thing happens in 2016 or if demand actually remains, much stronger, especially with prices as low as they are.  It is also becoming apparent that US production is falling, it is known that Canadian tar sands will soon be in seasonal maintenance, and OPEC/Russia is talking like they want to cap production/put a floor under prices.  This could mean current price levels are as good as they are going to get and it could spur demand in the next several weeks.  This is a dramatically different supply situation than this time 2015, since US production was still surging and tar sands didn't go into maintenance until summer.

My conclusion is it looks like it's time to by some gasoline and some refiners and probably crude as well.



EIA Overestimates US Production, Huge Production Drop in the Works #6

psw01 2016-2-24

I've been saying for quite awhile the EIA weekly production estimation model is way off.  It is also possible that since the US started exporting crude, an increase in exports could also be throwing off the model.  But from what I've read elsewhere, and what I've seen in well completion reporting I continue to believe the majority of the error is from overestimating lower 48 production.

This week Unaccounted for Oil was -320k bbl/day or 2.24MM bbl for the week.  This is the 4th week in a row for highly negative Unaccounted for Oil, which is totally unprecedented.  This adds to a string of 8 out of 12 weeks since Dec. 4 with highly negative Unaccounted for Oil.  Again very unprecedented.  But even more so when you consider Unaccounted for Oil has tended to run positive as detailed in my previous post EIA Overestimates US Production, .... #4.  In the last 4 weeks EIA models can't account for -11.7MM bbl of oil.  But they continue to tell everyone that US production is holding up pretty well even though Unaccounted for Oil is indicating has averaged -418k bbl/day over the last month, indicating US production could well be 4.6% lower than reported.  Do you think that might matter to some market participants?  The error looks a little less bad when you look at the 12 week period, which shows -14.5MM bbl that can't be explained or -173k bbl/day, a 2% error.

EIA monthly reports are just over a week away.  A prime opportunity for EIA to adjust their models.  Look out if they do, because this error will suddenly find its way into the weekly production estimates dragging them down very fast, potentially some weeks could show 75k-100k drops when this hits.  When it does, it will squeeze the shorts hard, because nobody expects this.  The speculative shorts are still at or near record short levels and the mainstream media continues to indicate US production is barely touched.  More importantly dropping US production will encourage OPEC to at least stick to a freeze and possibly redistribute quotas to enable Iran to increase production, ensuring they stick with the greater OPEC plan.

Many have called some of my predictions crazy, but my call on Unaccounted for Oil has been dead on for 3 months.  I expect my call on what is coming next for EIA weekly estimates to be correct as well.  Not to mention my call that when EIA estimated in January that February production would increase month over month was dead wrong.  After three weeks, the weekly data indicates February is down 0.89% over January, and that is using their overestimated numbers.  The real proof will be in the April monthly report, but it doesn't look very good thus far for the EIA estimate.

Below I'm including an update to my projection for Production + Unaccounted for Oil.  As predicted it continues to track in the lower portion of the channels and is tracking Projection 1 well.  Using polynomial curve fitting to project the future is also beginning to confirm this value will track the lower projection line as well.  I also noted these projections are based on WTI staying sub $50, the lower WTI stays the steeper the fall off.  At this point it may not matter much, US producers are in a semi-panic dropping appx. 30 rigs/week and any brief spike is unlikely to change their production plans anytime soon.  I expect very low well completion rates in February and March and rigs to be shutdown quickly until less than 300 are working in the oil fields.  I believe every shale CEO now knows to not jump back in too prematurely, even if they hedge.  It will just drive down/hold down prices for longer when they need to get back to turning a profit.
psw01 2016-2-24

Thursday, February 18, 2016

Refiners Aren't Acting Like Gasoline Demand is Weak, Even if Traders Are


Traders have been beating down the price of gasoline and gasoline crack spreads as well.  While refiners run at levels significantly higher than the same time in 2015 helping traders hold down gasoline prices and crack spreads.  With a huge inventory of crude, gasoline inventories seasonably high and a situation where WTI should supposedly stay low for a long time, why would refiners be pushing so hard, hurting their near term profits.

It seems there really can be only one answer.  Crude production is rapidly falling, and will continue to rapidly fall, and refiners know it.  Therefore they are sacrificing near term profits to create a hedge for the longer term by taking as much of what is currently ultra cheap crude, refining it and building stores of gasoline, distillates, etc. at a very low cost.


EIA Overestimates US Production, Huge Production Drop in the Works #5

The EIA weekly estimate of production is still too high as indicated by Unaccounted for Oil and production estimates based on well completion rates.  However, the weekly estimate is starting to move down in a big way.  Last week down 30k bbl/day, this week 50k bbl/day.  50k bbl/day is huge, that is 200k bbl/day/month  The reality is US production has been falling 20k-30k bbl/day for weeks or even months already, now it is likely falling 30-37k bbl/day/week not 50k bbl/day/week.  50k bbl/day/week would imply almost zero well completions, when around half of each months shale decline is currently being replaced monthly.  But EIA is so far behind, with likely production levels already below 9 MM bbl/day compared to the official estimate of 9.135 MM bbl/day, that they are being forced and will continue to be forced to show huge weekly declines for awhile to catch up.  Won't be surprised to see 100k bbl/day cut reported next week and potentially the week after as well.

Unaccounted for oil has been running dramatically negative since Dec. 4.  We have now just seen 3 back to back weeks with negative unaccounted for oil.  This week it was -500k bbl/day or 3.5MM bbl for the week.  Imagine what happens when -500k bbl/day in Unaccounted is zeroed out and put in production instead.