Friday, July 7, 2017

Not close to 222k jobs added in June 2017

Seasonally Adjusted Non-Farm Jobs Change 2013-Present:  Comparison between Griz Method/Simple YoY and BLS Monthly Reports
Source Data:  BLS
Total Nonfarm 2017-7. xlsx

I've been monitoring the inaccuracy and volatility in the monthly BLS jobs reports for several years now.  It is truly amazing to see how wild and inaccurate the monthly reporting of jobs gains is.  Hiring is not raging at a 222k/month pace as the most recent report claims.  184k/month is a lot closer to accurate.  About the only way to get a meaningful number from the BLS monthly jobs gain reported, is to average 12 months of data, and then the number tracks pretty close to reality.

The above chart makes it pretty clear that up to about December 2014 the monthly BLS report tended to over report jobs gains.  But since January 2015 it has been under reporting.  This can be seen by the blue and orange bars tracking pretty close in most months up to December 2014, with the orange bars periodically spiking over the blue.  But since January 2015 it the orange more typically track well below the blue.  Summing the difference between the orange and blue bars proves this as well.



Thursday, June 22, 2017

Housing Bubble 2.0

Housing Bubble 2.0


This looks like housing bubble 2.0.  Looks like houses are about 20-30% overpriced vs. a 3% inflation trend line.  Not good when wage inflation is only 2%.

Friday, May 26, 2017

The market can turn on a dime, NDX-100 Historical Chart


NDX-100 NASDAQ Index 2002 to May 2017

I'm posting this chart today because a friend of many told me that he was just starting to get aggressive in the market.  Actually in the process of rolling an annuity into something that would do better.  It struck me as classic behavior in a manic market top.  Nonsense, most would say.  Look how great the market is doing there is nothing stopping this.  Well look at the above chart.  What do you think the people were saying and doing in October 2007?  Do you think anyone that said the markets were about to crash in October 2007 were paid much heed?   But then look at November of 2007 and the following months.  It just got worse, with a single dead cat bounce.

The list of reasons why the conditions now are beginning to mimic those surrounding the housing bubble crash and dotcom crash is long.  And I plan to post on them in the future.  Virtually every line of reasoning used to dispel the bears can be easily be explained away as wrong or an outright lie.  The latest reason is that corporate earnings are up over 13% in the last year.

Here are some real numbers.  For fiscal 2016, Oct-Sept, corporate income tax payments were down 13% over 2015.  So if we are really up 13% earnings are at 2015 levels while stock prices are up 30%.  It looks like earnings have some real moving to do to justify the spike.  So let's look at a more recent period, the last 12 months.  Well that shows March 2016 to April 2107 corporate income tax payments were down 7.4% over the prior period.  And March 2015 to April 2016 were down 4% over the prior period.  It seems to me while some fancy corporate accounting was used to boost stock prices this last quarter, and others have written about this, the real trend is an accelerating decrease in corporate earnings as opposed to a sudden reversal to increasing earnings.  Maybe that is why the Schiller PE is 30.

Another recent reason for excitement was the 210k jobs supposedly added in April.  That was a giant lie as well.  With a multitude of store closings the report actually tried to claim retail jobs were up.  The underlying data set proves that was a lie/mistake.  The reality is about 175k jobs were added.  The job growth pace was about 1.45%., and in a decelerating trend  Guess what, in April 2007 the pace of job gains was about 1.25%  and decelerating.

Thursday, April 20, 2017

Corporate income tax payments comparison


Monthly Comparison of Corporate Income Taxes Paid  (In $Millions)  Orange highlight indicates monthly payments lower than same period in prior year, green highlight indicates greater payment.

Note:  The trend of falling corporate income tax payments and therefore likely corporate earnings remains intact.  With only $13B paid in March, April will need to be a huge month just to catch up.  There are no precedents for such low payments in March with a massive April makeup.  We'll know more when the April report comes out in mid May, but this doesn't look good.  This looks scarily similar to what we saw in 2008.  Back then it took 12-15 months for anyone to realize just how bad things were.  Looks like a repeat, and we are over 12 months into this earning recession with a skyrocketing stock market.  LOOK OUT!!!!





Wednesday, November 9, 2016

Was the October Jobs Report Really as Weak as it Appeared?

Seasonally Adjusted Non-Farm Jobs Change 2013-Present:  Comparison between Griz Method/Simple YoY and BLS Monthly Reports
Source Data:  BLS
Total Nonfarm 2016-11. xlsx
Tot Empl Chng, Seas Adj 2016-11

The October jobs report showed a top line non-farm employment gain of a weak 161k.  But how real is that number.  It certainly refutes my call of well over 200k to be reported.  I hope everyone is expecting huge job reports for October, November and December  Or does it?  Let's look closer.

First the September upward revision to the seasonally adjusted data was huge, from 156k to 191k, and the August 2nd revision up was 9k.  What this means is the September number is up 44k from what was originally reported, since you need to sum the two latest revisions, 9k+35k=44k   Looked at another way the October report showed 144.747MM jobs in September, and the latest report shows 144.791MM jobs for a difference of 44k.   So if we assume October eventually gets a big revision treatment getting the gain closer to 200k as recent trends suggest, that means 200k+44k in revisions gets very close to the 250k+ gain I predicted.  Certainly a 44k upward revision for September was huge and unexpected.

But let's dig even deeper.  Let's actually look at the revisions to the non-adjusted data set.  What we find is the August jobs total was actually adjusted DOWN 3k, while September was adjusted up a whopping 86k.  So if we take the originally reported seasonally adjusted number of 156k and add 86k, that totals 242k.  Which again lines up with my general call of very large months coming.

What does this mean for the future?  My data indicates about 288k jobs are still banked--that haven't shown up in the official seasonally adjusted reports.  However, there is a bit of a wild card.  What is unknown is how real the October number was.  If it is fairly accurate, it indicates hiring in October was very weak at only about a 186k monthly pace, down from about a 205k average the last few months.  So either the October data is foreshadowing very bad things to come, which the weekly unemployment reports are not confirming, or we can expect big numbers to come.  I expect a huge revision upward for October, and possibly a big September revision as well.  November could come in anywhere from 160k to 300k.  But the general theme will be big trailing month revisions and very good chance of a surprising November report.


Tuesday, October 25, 2016

I hope everyone is expecting huge job reports for October, November and December

Seasonally Adjusted Non-Farm Jobs Change 2013-Present:  Comparison between Griz Method/Simple YoY and BLS Monthly Reports
Source Data:  BLS
Total Nonfarm 2016-10. xlsx

For awhile now I've been showing how wild the monthly BLS seasonally adjusted jobs reports are.  I've said the timing of bad reports has done a great job of holding down interest rates, and the inevitable makeup reports have done an equally good job of pumping up stocks.  The latest cases occurred this summer and fall, with good reports pumping stocks, and then bad reports tabling rate hikes until December after the election.  How convenient!

The chart above shows the official monthly job gain was very low the last two months.  So it is apparent make up reports are on the way just by looking at it.   However, some math and deeper analysis confirms this.

First some basics.  The Griz method/YOY method of seasonal adjustment, moving averages, and moving averages from the seasonally adjusted data set all point to annual job gains pace of 2.4 million or 200k/month.

I decided to look at the BLS seasonally adjusted data set a bit closer to see if there was a way to predict coming reports a little better.  So what I decided to do a 12 month summation of the reported monthly gains.  This really does the same thing as a 12 month moving average, but it provides a table that provided additional insight into how this mathematically works.  What I found is that each month, is that the sum of the most recent 12 month gains lines up relatively closely with they YoY change from the nonadjusted data set.  Makes sense.  However, the summation can vary up to +/-5% from the YoY number.  5% error is about 120k on 2.4 million, large but not so large that it is always obvious without specifically looking.  It could mean BLS reports 190k monthly gains instead of 200k.  What is also glaring is this 5% error is far less than the wild variations that take the reports into the low to mid 100k range and near 300k some months, when it is pretty clear the numbers have really been in the 200k-240k range.

So What is Coming  

Using the table of 12 month summations shown below it becomes somewhat trivial to predict the coming months reports assuming recent hiring trends remain basically intact.  At this point based on weekly jobless claims that seems to be the case.


Table of 12 Month Job Gain Summations using BLS Monthly Reported Seasonally Adjusted Gains (In 1000s of jobs)  
Data Source:  BLS
Total non farm, adj 2016-10.xlsx

Looking at the table we can see the 12 month summation for October 2016 is 2.152 million which includes 0 gains for October which hasn't been reported yet.  So if we assume the real trend is around 2.4 million like it has been for the last 5 months, that means BLS needs to report a 291k gain to get the numbers to line up exactly with reality/the Griz method/make the long term averages right.  If we factor in potential skewing and other random factors from the BLS, the likely range for October is 250k-300k.  Far above expectations with August and September reported around 160k.

Then if we apply a 291k gain for October, the expected reported gain for November should the trend hold is about 287k.  Including 287k for November then predicts a 271k reported gain for December should the trend hold.

My calculations show that currently about 300k jobs are "banked" due to under reporting in early 2016.  Analysis going into 2015 shows when this "banked" number is close to 300k, a huge report is in store.  These huge reports quickly eat into the bank.  A 300k report would reduce the bank by 80k-100k.  History also shows that as the bank comes down the likelihood of a huge report the next month drops.  So it is really hard to know whether the December report will end up being really big, but it is very likely both the October and November reports will be in the 250k-290k range.

My investment plans are to short treasuries with ETFs and with futures.  I also expect that this will trigger a massive stock correction or even crash to end 2016 and/or start 2017 when rate hikes become apparent and actually are implemented no later than December.  A November rate hike is not out of the question, but I don't think the Fed will do anything to spook markets ahead of the election.